The Panthers, two-time Section 1 finalists, got the game-winning goal from freshman attacker Brian Reda (two goals) with 5:50 remaining.
Senior captain Baylor Rosenbaum also had two goals for Pleasantville, and Bryan Archie had a goal and two assists.
Cullen Morgan had a goal and an assist for the Foxes, and Tom Tenney, Dan Tracy, Matt Leader and Matt Magnan each scored for the Foxes.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Pleasantville and receive free news updates.